
Over the past two decades, film and television production incentives have become one of the most competitive economic development tools employed by state and local governments. From Georgia’s booming “Hollywood of the South” to New Mexico’s strategic positioning as a production hub, jurisdictions across the United States have invested billions in tax credits, rebates, and infrastructure to attract entertainment industry spending. But what does the data actually reveal about the economic impact of these programs?
Understanding Production Incentives: More Than Just Tax Breaks
Film and television production incentives typically take three primary forms: transferable tax credits, cash rebates, or sales tax exemptions on production-related purchases. These programs are designed to attract location filming and production activity that would otherwise occur elsewhere—or potentially not occur at all.
The mechanics vary by jurisdiction. Some states offer 20-40% rebates on qualified in-state spending, while others provide tax credits that can offset state tax liability or be sold to third parties. Many programs include wage requirements, stipulating that a certain percentage of cast and crew must be state residents, or that productions must spend a minimum threshold within the state to qualify.
The fundamental economic question underlying these programs is straightforward: do the tax revenues generated by induced economic activity, combined with broader economic benefits, exceed the cost of the incentives provided?
The Multiplier Effect: Following the Production Dollar
When a major production spends $50 million in a state, that initial injection creates rippling economic effects throughout the regional economy. Production companies hire local crew members, rent equipment, secure locations, book hotels, and purchase materials from area suppliers. Those workers and businesses, in turn, spend their earnings on housing, food, retail, and services—generating successive rounds of economic activity.
Economic impact methodology typically distinguishes between three categories of effects:
Direct impacts represent the initial production spending itself: wages paid to cast and crew, equipment rentals, construction materials for sets, catering services, and location fees. This is the most straightforward component to measure and verify.
Indirect impacts capture the inter-industry effects as production-related businesses purchase goods and services from other local businesses. When a production company rents cameras from a local equipment house, that vendor may purchase insurance from a local broker, maintenance from local technicians, and supplies from local retailers.
Induced impacts reflect the household spending that occurs when workers employed directly or indirectly by the production spend their earnings in the local economy—buying groceries, paying rent, dining at restaurants, and purchasing consumer goods.
The total economic impact is typically expressed as a multiplier. A production with $50 million in direct spending might generate $80-100 million in total economic output when indirect and induced effects are included. However, multiplier magnitudes vary significantly based on local economic conditions, industry cluster development, and the extent to which spending actually remains within the regional economy versus leaking out to suppliers in other states.
Beyond the Headlines: Quantifying Real Economic Returns
The most visible metric associated with production incentives—total production spending attracted—often obscures more complex economic realities. A state that reports attracting $500 million in production spending doesn’t necessarily capture $500 million in local economic benefit.
First, not all production spending qualifies for incentives or occurs within the incentivizing jurisdiction. Many programs only rebate “qualified production expenditures,” which typically exclude above-the-line costs like producer fees, star salaries, and rights acquisitions. A production with a $100 million budget might have only $60 million in qualified local spending.
Second, even qualified spending doesn’t always represent new economic activity. If a state already has an active production industry, some incentivized projects might have occurred anyway. The critical analytical question becomes: what portion of production activity represents truly incremental spending that wouldn’t have occurred “but for” the incentive program?
Third, fiscal impact differs from economic impact. While a production might generate $100 million in economic output, the net fiscal return to state and local governments depends on tax revenues generated minus incentive costs and any additional public service expenses. Studies examining fiscal ROI have found highly variable results, with some programs generating positive returns and others showing substantial net costs to state treasuries.
Job Creation: Temporary Positions vs. Industry Development
Employment generation represents one of the most politically salient benefits claimed for production incentive programs. A major television series filming in a state might employ 500-1,000 people over several months, while a feature film provides shorter-term employment for smaller crews.
However, employment impacts require nuanced analysis. Many production jobs are temporary, lasting only for the duration of filming. In states with limited existing production infrastructure, above-the-line positions (directors, cinematographers, lead actors) often go to out-of-state workers who travel with the production. Below-the-line positions (grips, electricians, production assistants) provide better opportunities for local hiring but require specialized skills that may not exist in the local workforce.
The long-term employment benefits depend significantly on whether a jurisdiction succeeds in building sustainable production infrastructure. States that have attracted multiple recurring productions—particularly television series that film for multiple seasons—have seen development of skilled local workforces, production facilities, and supporting business ecosystems. Georgia, for example, has built a legitimate production industry with year-round employment opportunities, film schools producing trained workers, and substantial infrastructure investment.
Conversely, states that attract only sporadic productions may see minimal lasting employment effects. Workers hired for one-off projects often face unemployment after production wraps, and the local economy may not develop the critical mass of activity necessary to sustain service providers and specialized vendors.
Infrastructure Investment and Long-Term Industry Development
The most substantial long-term economic benefits from production incentives may come not from individual projects but from catalyzing broader industry development. States that have successfully competed for production activity have seen investment in soundstages, post-production facilities, equipment rental houses, and specialized service providers.
New Mexico’s investment in production infrastructure illustrates this dynamic. The state’s combination of tax incentives and direct investment in facilities like Albuquerque Studios helped attract major productions and encouraged private sector investment in supporting infrastructure. Over time, this created a self-reinforcing cycle where the presence of infrastructure made the state more attractive for future productions, which in turn justified additional infrastructure investment.
Similarly, Georgia’s growth as a production hub has attracted ancillary investments in visual effects studios, post-production facilities, and entertainment industry services. These businesses provide year-round employment and serve multiple clients, creating more stable economic benefits than individual productions.
Infrastructure development also generates educational and workforce development opportunities. States with active production industries have seen growth in film school programs, technical training initiatives, and apprenticeship opportunities that build human capital with applications beyond the entertainment industry.
Tourism and Place Marketing: The Intangible Multiplier
Beyond direct production spending and employment, filmed entertainment can generate significant tourism impacts through what economists term “induced visitation” or the “film tourism” effect. Locations featured in successful productions often see increased visitor interest, with tourists seeking to experience settings they recognize from screen.
New Zealand’s tourism industry, for instance, received a substantial boost from the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit film series, with dedicated tours to filming locations becoming significant attractions. Closer to home, locations featured in Breaking Bad generate tourism revenue for Albuquerque, while Savannah leverages its appearance in numerous films and television shows as a marketing asset.
However, quantifying tourism impacts poses methodological challenges. Isolating the specific contribution of filmed entertainment from other tourism drivers requires sophisticated analysis. Visitors may come for multiple reasons, making it difficult to attribute spending solely to a location’s appearance on screen. Additionally, tourism effects tend to be most pronounced for iconic, widely-viewed productions and may be negligible for less successful projects.
The place marketing value of production activity extends beyond tourism to broader economic development. Positive media portrayals can enhance a jurisdiction’s image, potentially influencing business location decisions, talent recruitment, and residential migration patterns. While difficult to quantify precisely, these perception effects may represent meaningful long-term economic value.
The Cost Side of the Equation: Fiscal Sustainability Concerns
Production incentive programs have faced increasing scrutiny regarding their fiscal sustainability and opportunity costs. The fundamental concern is whether foregone tax revenue and direct expenditures on incentives exceed the fiscal benefits generated through induced economic activity.
Academic studies examining production incentive ROI have found mixed results. Research has identified several states where fiscal costs substantially exceed fiscal benefits, with taxpayers effectively subsidizing production activity that generates limited lasting economic value. Fiscal breakeven typically requires that every dollar of incentive spending generates additional tax revenue exceeding that dollar—a threshold many programs fail to meet.
The opportunity cost dimension matters as well. Funds allocated to production incentives represent resources unavailable for alternative uses—education, infrastructure, health services, or other economic development initiatives that might generate greater economic returns. Comprehensive cost-benefit analysis should compare production incentive investments against the next-best alternative use of public funds.
Program design significantly influences fiscal outcomes. Incentives that include strong wage requirements, local hiring preferences, and spending thresholds tend to generate better fiscal returns than more permissive programs. Transferable tax credits can be more expensive than direct rebates if credits trade at substantial discounts, effectively increasing subsidy costs. States that cap annual incentive expenditures and conduct regular program evaluations tend to achieve better fiscal management than those with open-ended commitments.
Measuring What Matters: The Challenge of Rigorous Impact Assessment
Conducting rigorous economic impact analysis of production incentive programs presents significant methodological challenges. The analytical framework must address several critical questions:
Causality and attribution: To what extent did the incentive program cause production activity that wouldn’t otherwise have occurred? Productions that would have filmed in the state regardless of incentives represent deadweight loss, while truly incremental activity represents program success. Determining causality requires understanding decision-making factors and competitive dynamics in the production industry.
Displacement effects: Does production industry growth displace other economic activity? If skilled workers shift from other industries to production work, or if production activity occupies real estate that would otherwise house different businesses, the net economic impact is reduced. Some studies have found that production booms can create upward pressure on costs in related industries, potentially displacing other activity.
Dynamic effects over time: Short-term impacts during active production differ substantially from long-term economic development outcomes. Rigorous analysis must examine whether temporary production activity catalyzes sustained industry development or simply creates ephemeral employment.
Appropriate geographic scope: Should analysis focus on state-level impacts, regional effects, or more localized outcomes? Production activity concentrated in major metro areas may generate limited benefits for rural communities, even as state taxpayers collectively fund incentives.
Counterfactual scenarios: What would have occurred in the absence of the incentive program? Establishing appropriate counterfactuals requires understanding competitive dynamics, alternative location attractiveness, and the elasticity of production location decisions to incentive levels.
Economic consulting firms with expertise in impact assessment employ sophisticated modeling techniques to address these challenges, including input-output analysis calibrated to local economic conditions, econometric analysis of causal effects, and fiscal impact modeling that traces revenue effects through different government accounts.
Best Practices for Program Design and Evaluation
Jurisdictions considering or operating production incentive programs can improve outcomes through thoughtful program design and rigorous evaluation:
Set clear objectives and metrics: Programs should articulate specific goals—whether job creation, industry development, tourism enhancement, or fiscal return—and establish measurable success criteria. Vague aspirations make performance assessment impossible.
Include strong performance requirements: Tying incentive levels to outcomes like local hiring percentages, workforce training commitments, or minimum spending thresholds helps ensure programs generate intended benefits.
Cap expenditures and build in sunset provisions: Limiting annual program costs and requiring periodic reauthorization creates natural evaluation points and prevents runaway spending.
Conduct independent evaluations: Regular, methodologically rigorous assessments by independent evaluators provide objective performance data and inform program adjustments. Evaluations should employ appropriate counterfactual analysis and examine both economic and fiscal impacts.
Coordinate with broader industry development strategies: Incentives work best as part of comprehensive approaches that include workforce training, infrastructure investment, and business ecosystem development. Standalone tax credits without supporting initiatives may attract transient activity without building sustainable industries.
Maintain transparency: Publishing program costs, participating productions, and economic impact data enables public accountability and informed policy debate.
The Path Forward: Evidence-Based Policy Development
Film and television production incentives represent significant public investments with complex, multifaceted economic impacts. While these programs have unquestionably attracted substantial production activity to competitive states, the net economic and fiscal benefits vary considerably based on program design, local economic conditions, and broader industry development success.
Policymakers considering production incentives should approach these programs with realistic expectations and commitment to rigorous evaluation. The most successful initiatives combine competitive incentives with strategic investments in infrastructure and workforce development, building sustainable industries rather than chasing individual productions. They also implement strong performance requirements, fiscal controls, and regular independent assessment to ensure taxpayer resources generate meaningful returns.
For jurisdictions already operating production incentive programs, periodic evaluation using sophisticated analytical methods provides essential feedback for program refinement. Understanding which elements drive positive outcomes and which represent less effective spending enables evidence-based policy adjustments that improve program performance.
As the competitive landscape for production activity continues to evolve, with new jurisdictions entering the market and existing programs adjusting their offerings, the need for sophisticated economic analysis has never been greater. Decision-makers require defensible, methodologically rigorous assessments that quantify both benefits and costs, enabling informed choices about public resource allocation.
Understanding the Full Economic Picture
Whether you’re a policymaker evaluating a production incentive proposal, an economic development organization seeking to quantify program impacts, or a jurisdiction considering program adjustments, comprehensive economic analysis provides the foundation for sound decision-making. At Stratford Analytics, we specialize in rigorous economic impact assessment and cost-benefit analysis that meets the highest professional standards and withstands stakeholder scrutiny.
Our economic consulting team brings deep expertise in measuring complex economic development program impacts, employing sophisticated modeling techniques calibrated to local economic conditions and industry-specific factors. We help clients understand not just headline spending numbers, but the true fiscal and economic returns from incentive investments.
If your organization is evaluating production incentive programs or needs defensible economic impact analysis to support policy decisions, grant applications, or strategic planning, we invite you to explore how data-driven insights can inform better outcomes. Learn more about our economic development consulting services at stratfordanalytics.com or reach out to discuss your specific analytical needs.